Plugged In

Analysts: Modern Warfare 3 to outsell Battlefield 3

Battlefield 3 (EA)For the past few months, the war of words between Activision and Electronic Arts over their respective modern military shooters has been intense, to say the least. EA has been eager to unseat Call of Duty from its king-of-the-hill spot and hasn't shied away from trash talking to do so.

On Tuesday, the company's best bet to accomplish this — Battlefield 3 — will hit store shelves. And while EA's marketing machine is about to go into overdrive, analysts say the fight may be over before it starts.

Modern Warfare 3, due out Nov. 8, will sell twice as many units as Battlefield 3 this year, predicts Michael Pachter, an analyst with Wedbush Securities. He also believes it will likely set entertainment opening weekend records for the third year in a row.

The good news for EA? While that might sound like a walloping, both companies are positioned to be big winners. Pachter says he expects the latest Modern Warfare to sell 16 million units by the end of the fourth quarter (and another 8 million next year). Battlefield, he says, should sell about 8 million this year and another 2 million in 2012.

"I'd guess that around half of the console copies of Battlefield 3 will be bought by people who also buy Modern Warfare 3, so around 2 to 3 million will buy both," he said. "I don't see much cannibalization of the titles."

Other analysts are a bit more optimistic about Battlefield 3's sales numbers. Eric Handler of MKM Partners recently upped his 2011 projections of the game to 8.5 million.

Together, the two titles could generate 15 percent of the total brick and mortar game sales between October and December, bringing in over $1.4 billion, a staggering sum.

Still, Battlefield 3 isn't without its problems. EA let certain outlets review the PC version of the game, but no console reviews will be out until it lands on store shelves — and that has some gamers nervous. The company has further confirmed reports that Xbox 360 players who want to experience the game at its graphical best will need to install an HD "texture pack," which gobbles up 2 GB of their system's hard drive.

If you choose not to, beware. The game you play won't look at all like what you've seen in the eye-popping commercials.

Join us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter!
 

22 comments

  • f c  •  6 months ago
    BF3 is for the hardcore shooter, MW3 will be nothing more then a re-skinned version of MW2, same engine, and prolly same outdated DX9 graphics..... shame really, COD used to be a good game and now just a repetitive piece of garbage...... activision is charging you 60.00 for a MW2 map pack and renamed perks basically.
  • Anthony  •  6 months ago
    Doesn't surprise me. Consumers will buy the same piece of junk with several times over, even though they know it is sub-par. I'm getting battlefield anyway, so no big deal.
  • MichaelS  •  6 months ago
    anyone having issues connecting to Battlefield 3 online?
    • A Yahoo! User 6 months ago
      The Beta expired dude. I think. Every Beta has to expire. And tonight is the Alphas release. So it makes sense.
    • Brian 6 months ago
      I keep losing connection too. I was able to connect for about 2 hours....but then it started saying that EA connection was lost.
  • mainjet  •  6 months ago
    BF3 is everything as advertised, graphics, game play, vehicles, all in amazing detail, yes I have an amazing pc (home built gaming monster). All I can say is if your console gamer, it sucks to be you. All I ever hear from consolers' are complaints about crappy graphics,crappy online experiences(campers,kids, general dweebs) and how disappointed they are when a game doesn't look nearly as clean as they expected. Be a real gamer, go with pc.
    • Zachary 6 months ago
      PC, I admit, is the way to go. But, I cannot afford to build a gaming PC. I have tried, but always fail due to lack of parts. Console is probably my gaming device because all I have to do, is go to the store, buy a game, come home, pop the disk in, enjoy a few hours of pure gaming. Graphics? I don't give a care. If it equals the graphics of any call of duty has come out since World at War, I will play it. I don't need ULTRA realism. I just need good content.
  • Benjamin H  •  6 months ago
    Is this really newsworthy? Of course its going to sell more. It was never about selling more then CoD. But once people see how amazing bf3 is they will figure out whats the better game. A completely new game? Or a rehashed game thats been the same for the past 3 years?
    • EliteMon95 6 months ago
      A new game? BF3 is BC2 with more green plants a different story and planes.
  • Alfred Villanueva  •  6 months ago
    Okay this is actually good news to BF3 players we dont get the 10-14 year old kids talkin vrap and ” quickscoping” anyways I havent found a single kid who does this in BF3 my descision is awesome!
  • Zachary  •  6 months ago
    To me BF3 is OK. It isn't all that good. It focuses on strategy and teamwork. It also forces the player to walk or drive around the map looking for the battle 75% of the time. There are many snipers who can hide and camp easily due to the excessive foliage. You will pretty much ALWAYS get busted by a tank or bigger vehicle. To me, Battlefield is all about who has the bigger weapon. I walk around with an SMG, a guy comes up to me and says, "An m16? FACE THE POWER OF MY TANK!" and runs me over in a second. I'm on a killing spree and I randomly get blow to bits by artillery that I had no clue was going to hit me. I'm getting ready to pump lead into a guy with my tank's machine gun and a jet comes around and bombs the heck out of me. Yes, I have owned all the battlefields, so yes, I can talk. COD is my game. It focuses on reflexes. It does not matter who has the better gun, it matters who is wielding the gun. I was playing Black Ops the other day, and I was rank 10 and was up against people who were rank 40+. I OWNED with my puny m14. And ended up WINNING the team deathmatch. COD also has very small maps, and I can find the battle fairly quickly. Graphics? I DON'T care. Content makes the difference in my gaming life. Vehicles? Be glad they don't have those. I remember playing World at War a few years back, and finding that at EVERY SINGLE LEVEL the tanks would provide an almost instant win for their team. Who cares if you had Satchel Charges, they would see you a mile away. It was very un-balanced. BF3 only puts vehicles in because it has big maps. Small maps+vehicles=chaos. I do have to give credit to BF though, because they did provide me with Battlefield 1942, Battlefield Vietnam and Battlefield 1943. I did enjoy those games and gladly played 1942 and Vietnam on my PC (just so I could mod and use cheats). In the end, it seems that those who enjoy big maps, awesome sniping and TANK LOADS of vehicles (pun intended) need to get BF. COD favors those who can think quick, who have trigger-happy fingers, and those who favor small, but EXTREMELY dicey maps. There is no battle, these are two VERY different sub-genre's in the FPS category. There is no fight, BF is strategic, COD is fast-paced, two very different game who have their own different groups. Today's gaming world is F***** if we are going to argue over who has the best graphics. We are all gamers and should not be whiny babies about two games. THEY ARE GAMES. SHUT UP and play your game and let us play ours. (Sorry for the enormous comment, but I had to get my point across, even though none of you will listen).
  • Nodor  •  6 months ago
    Already pre-ordered MW3...I'll rent BF3 when I done with that one.

    Thought this 'texture pack' had better be a free download, or I won't even bother.
    • Brian 6 months ago
      it is a free download. takes 2 minutes. but i think it just takes up to much space. oh well.
  • Kyle  •  6 months ago
    Battle Field is the better series BY FAR, COD is too cartoony for my liking. What we really need is a new Rainbow Six .
    • Parkie 6 months ago
      and add early Ghost Recon and Splinter Cell, you'd have a Champion
  • Robert  •  6 months ago
    another thing is i got the 2010 medal of honor not as good as the original maybe becuase dice took over or becuse EA needed a new developer
  • Robert  •  6 months ago
    COD will outsell ofcourse becuase cod has a new game just about every year but i was there for the launch of battlefield 3 and as soon as i started playing i couldnt stop but another thing that came to my mind is what ever happened to medal of honor wasnt it better than cod before? any ways bf3 is one of the best ive played so far next to gears of war.
  • austin  •  6 months ago
    i personally think that BF3 is not that great of a game, and i would choose any CoD game over battle field. im so excited for MW3 to come out. all the people who keep saying its going to be the same are the people who havnt taken the time to see or read about the new details.
  • Neil  •  6 months ago
    And this is news how? I mean, I don't even like Call of Duty (and I suck at Battlefield), and I knew this. Even EA, contrary to some of their previous trash talk/boasts, admit that they don't expect Battlefield 3 to beat Modern Warfare in terms of sales. What they want is for it to take a portion of the Call of Duty fanbase, and make them fans of Battlefield as well, so over the years Battlefield may become as big as CoD is now.
  • kasey  •  6 months ago
    Just played through 2 missions today (ps3) and graphics are not like the commercials and trailers. Very disappointed and feel mislead. Tree & building textures reminded me of homefront and taking out the sniper in the hotel is nothing like the video they posted. laughable really.. Should of figured that all that hype was a polished pc version. Might not stick in my library for the long haul. Be Warned before purchase, save it for UC3!
  • Kyle  •  6 months ago
    Played both series in the past, and played BF3 last night on PC. Spectacular graphics I am really impressed, amazing, cant say enough good things. Kudos to EA well done on this one really well done. Looking forward to comparing to MWF3 next month.
  • A Yahoo! User  •  6 months ago
    Dude, I like both. But... its hard to say but... I think that BF3 willl win. Look at all the stuff you can do in BF3? You can fly airplanes over the ground battlefield, drive tanks, boats, UAVs. What can MW3 do? Yeah. Think about it.
  • Eric  •  6 months ago
    Well what i think is that Trinity doesnt know when to end its series and battlefield focuses on the one thing other games dont, teamwork
  • Lethrblaka  •  6 months ago
    Bought the limited edition of BF3, and it gives me free access to an expansion pack! What will the LE of MW3 give you, free access to a urine sample?LOL, wannabes will definitely flock to get MW3 just to be popular in school!
  • Wolfy  •  6 months ago
    same shit different year.....i just hope one of them sells well to help this sad economy
  • Karl  •  6 months ago
    One persons guess does not mean it will happen.
POLL

What is the Greatest Music Game of all time?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options